Should MotoGP bikes be more restricted like NASCAR?
With all the discussion that MotoGP is "boring" or uncompetitive, is there something that can be done to make the races closer at the finish line?...NASCAR has this in place, and no one EVER has a huge lead at the finish line...
So, is that the answer? |
I vote no, BTW...I'm a "run what you brung" kind of guy...
|
No way. Ease up the fuel restrictions, and/or make the tires crappier.
|
Prototype racing is supposed to showcase technology. Restricting that in any way makes it irrelevant
|
Quote:
"Equal" classes are fine, but if they don't have the slightest resemblence to a commercially available vehicle *ahem* NASCAR *ahem* don't pretend they do. |
Quote:
|
Ahhhh hells no!
|
What kills MotoGP, IMHO, is "satellite" team racing. It's stupid to send two Ducatis and 3 or four Hondas and a couple of Yamahas out there on CLEARLY inferior bikes (often with engines and frames that are a season or two old) and then call it "racing."
It's NOT a competition if it's rigged so that only 3 or 4 bikes have a legimate chance to win and the other riders are just out there to "fill out" (though it's embarrassing to say that for MotoGP with only 17 riders when everyone is healthy) the grid. Honda and Ducati and Yamaha should send everyone out on "factory" bikes.....no glaring technology gaps within the same brand.....you ride for Yamaha, you get the best Yamaha prototype available....same as Honda and Ducati....best rider wins. I honestly don't know how they talk kids into leaving Moto2 or WSB to go ride a bike that they KNOW has NO chance to win in MotoGP. I think that ridding the field of all the electronic aids would be a HUGE step in the right direction too. What seperates the winners from the losers? The size of their balls and their skill on 2 wheels....not how good their ECU engineer in Japan is. |
Tony Elias feels your pain...
|
Quote:
Quote:
|
Fortunately with racing motorcycles the style and skill of the rider have a much greater effect in the overall performance than just using the same engines, chassis ect.
Moto2 is a prime example of how you can use the same engine and ecu and get different results thanks partially to open chassis rules but the different rider styles and abilities seem to come out at each circuit. Not saying that a NASCAR driver doesnt have tracks that his style favors, I am just saying that if that driver has a shit set up that weekend it wont matter how well he wheels a car, someone with the right set up will beat him. I raced dirt track ovals in cars for about 7-8 years and there is only so much you can do with the car if you miss the set up, usually only about two lines thru a corner thanks to the heavy wide nature of the cars. You can hustle the thing a little but physics takes over eventually. Bikes have a broader spectrum of lines, styles, and even when you get on a guys bike that owns the lap record, if you dont have his style his set up isnt going to agree but you can still hustle it once you find out how to agree with it (ala Stoner and the Ducati). |
Fuck that shit... completely unrestricted... Engine size should be the only standard...
|
Quote:
|
Are there, or have there ever been completely unrestricted race classes?
|
IMO there should be NO restrictions. Save the rules for the superbike level.
I'd rather my sport keep the restrictions to the customer based level vs the unobtainum. We already can't buy GP bikes(realistically), so I think it would provide more sport/entertainment to see such an awesome level of technology and advancement. |
Poll fail. There's no "Fuck No" option.
|
Quote:
|
DMG and AMA should be a lesson to us all. We need an unrestricted class. I would like to see a return to 2 strokes! What a series it would be with bikes running 750 to 1k two strokes! I'd watch that
|
Moto GP is for prototypes, if you want to watch racing watch superbike.
|
I would like to watch Simoncelli ride thru the field on a 750 two stroke
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
Plus we can all smile when someone puts a Tech3 bike on the podium once a year or so. :lol: |
"...we can all smile when someone puts a Tech3 bike on the podium once a year or so"
Can't agree with you more :D or if like say kyle busch were to sell the nascar experience |
All times are GMT -4. The time now is 11:30 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions Inc.